Why just why these videos keep saying that Joshua's or Seventeen's fans are against him dating when 99% of the carats are totally fine with them dating, married or have children.
Every shirt and other item is not made for 1 item only.. Don't be too short minded, not only Joshua has the same item as that girl, everyone also has a shirt @ accessories like that..
Tomorrow or someday they all have to marry someone…does fans want them to be single forever ?? Does those fans will be single forever waiting for them?? Who the Fuck are those fan to humiliate their idols…Let them be happy in their life 🙏
joshua is literally turning 28 this year let that man live he’s a grown man n knows what he’s doing. even if the rumors are real it’s none of our business. i never understood why ppl get mad ab when idols r dating but ones they’re married they turn 180 n suddenly become supportive
+ this video is clickbait pls do something better like taking a walk outside or read a book bc u can clearly not mind ur own business
For 4 months now, all fans of Korea, China and America are sure Joshua has relantionship with one girl, she is a mestizo Chechenka and Korean, she grew up and lives in Korea very beautiful natural tall 18-year-old singer actrees and photo model
I don't understand why anybody or someone can't stop spreading rumors about dating SEVENTEEN or any k-pop group if you don't get any official news from this agency, that means the rumors are FAKE!! Tired of hearing these dating rumors, and, nobody can hurt SEVENTEEN, but CARAT here with SEVENTEEN #protectseventeen
I just came here to check how ridiculous this video could be lol. Yall should calm down with those videos and ultra clickbaitey titles. Not only is this not confirmed but involves a person whos more private than him and potentially harmful to her.
I don't know why people do it like this ….. its his life …. he is not a child that you all haters will hate him…. if he love someone it's okay … respect that but don't judge with similar photos or video's…. it's really bad … 🥲🤧
Mi pregunta es porque la agencia no se a pronunciado? porque dejar que esto llegue tan lejos? no se dan cuenta que el único perjudicado es Joshua si es mentira.
If you have a partner in your life as a husband or wife, a boyfriend or girlfriend do Seventeen abandon you as a member of the SVT fandom?
Does SVT go through fan's personal life?
If they do these things to you, please you have the right to leave the fandom as soon as possible
SVT is a global Kpop band, because of these ridiculous fans SVT will have a black mark on their celebrity life so don't become an interrupted fan of your artist
Artists have the right to live a full life, they have to know about society although an affair is not a bad thing to an artist right they also have feelings and tastes in their own ways. anyway, they are even getting ready for their own personal life military service, marriage, etc.
As a Carat we have to help and encourage them in the future
Then you can say you are a true Carat one day.
DON'T RUN THROUGH JOSHUA'S PERSONAL LIFE, PLEASE GIVE HIM SOME LOVE AND SUPPORT
I KNOW HIM SINCE 2015
HE IS A BRIGHT ARTIST EVEN INSIDE HIS HEART
HE IS HAVING A SUPER HARD TIME BECAUSE OF THESE SH*T COMMENTS
bro im so damn pissed by this stupid channel whats with all the crazy video titles on joshua that they post carats pls report all these videos they are literally trying to get views through spreading rumours and dragging joshua’s name in the dirt
What is wrong with "Netizens"?! When will these idols who work so hard to entertain us be allowed the freedom to have relationships – they are not our possessions and here we are forcing them down the same dangerous spiral that so many other idols and celebrities have been sadly lost to – LEAVE THEM ALONE! It is time for entertainment companies and fans alike to relax the "rules" and expectations for all idols – learn the lessons from the past!
First of all plz change the title we don't want joshua to get more hate just because of this stupid videos that are only made for views. Second Carats let's support joshua and leave positive comments under his posts!! We don't care if he dates it's his private life and us fans should not care about it, and most of the hate is coming form antis so i hipe this situation gets better soon ❤ Let's protect joshua❤
This model is married, she is not his girlfriend, she is him fan, another girl maches a lot of touching moments. 18-year-old very beautiful, natural, tall, blue-eyed idol actress and photo model. she is mestizo. She is Chechenka and Korean. She was born in Korea, grew up in Korea and lives fans Joshua are sure that he is dating in 18 years old girl
27 Comments
Why just why these videos keep saying that Joshua's or Seventeen's fans are against him dating when 99% of the carats are totally fine with them dating, married or have children.
Every shirt and other item is not made for 1 item only.. Don't be too short minded, not only Joshua has the same item as that girl, everyone also has a shirt @ accessories like that..
she's already married
I don't know why people are so much interested on their private life. Like, Carats are absolutely fine as long as seventeen is happy.
Whaaaat!?
Even if he dating someone who gives a shit , he’s almost 30
He can do what he wants unless it’s illegal
bro nobody should care 💀 if u care sm about a grown man dating youre just weird
anlahuy kwento mo sa lola mo!
Tomorrow or someday they all have to marry someone…does fans want them to be single forever ?? Does those fans will be single forever waiting for them?? Who the Fuck are those fan to humiliate their idols…Let them be happy in their life 🙏
joshua is literally turning 28 this year let that man live he’s a grown man n knows what he’s doing. even if the rumors are real it’s none of our business. i never understood why ppl get mad ab when idols r dating but ones they’re married they turn 180 n suddenly become supportive
+ this video is clickbait pls do something better like taking a walk outside or read a book bc u can clearly not mind ur own business
nah me and joshua have been dating for the past 5 years 🙂 we were breathing the same air the entire time
There is nothing between this and Joshua, this girl is married
For 4 months now, all fans of Korea, China and America are sure Joshua has relantionship with one girl, she is a mestizo Chechenka and Korean, she grew up and lives in Korea very beautiful natural tall 18-year-old singer actrees and photo model
I think Cho mi young is a fan of Joshua. That's why she bought matching clothes with Joshua, always think positive
I don't understand why anybody or someone can't stop spreading rumors about dating SEVENTEEN or any k-pop group if you don't get any official news from this agency, that means the rumors are FAKE!! Tired of hearing these dating rumors, and, nobody can hurt SEVENTEEN, but CARAT here with SEVENTEEN #protectseventeen
I just came here to check how ridiculous this video could be lol. Yall should calm down with those videos and ultra clickbaitey titles. Not only is this not confirmed but involves a person whos more private than him and potentially harmful to her.
키스는 연기때문에 한거 아닌가요?
Whats the problem tho 😂😂
I don't know why people do it like this ….. its his life …. he is not a child that you all haters will hate him…. if he love someone it's okay … respect that but don't judge with similar photos or video's…. it's really bad … 🥲🤧
My question just one, how much they pay u for make this some nonsense video?
Gue pengen bgt ngomong kasar yaaa fag
Mi pregunta es porque la agencia no se a pronunciado? porque dejar que esto llegue tan lejos? no se dan cuenta que el único perjudicado es Joshua si es mentira.
Hey, this comment is for the SVT Fans Carat only:
If you have a partner in your life as a husband or wife, a boyfriend or girlfriend do Seventeen abandon you as a member of the SVT fandom?
Does SVT go through fan's personal life?
If they do these things to you, please you have the right to leave the fandom as soon as possible
SVT is a global Kpop band, because of these ridiculous fans SVT will have a black mark on their celebrity life so don't become an interrupted fan of your artist
Artists have the right to live a full life, they have to know about society although an affair is not a bad thing to an artist right they also have feelings and tastes in their own ways. anyway, they are even getting ready for their own personal life military service, marriage, etc.
As a Carat we have to help and encourage them in the future
Then you can say you are a true Carat one day.
DON'T RUN THROUGH JOSHUA'S PERSONAL LIFE, PLEASE GIVE HIM SOME LOVE AND SUPPORT
I KNOW HIM SINCE 2015
HE IS A BRIGHT ARTIST EVEN INSIDE HIS HEART
HE IS HAVING A SUPER HARD TIME BECAUSE OF THESE SH*T COMMENTS
PLEASE LEAVE HIM ALONE
bro im so damn pissed by this stupid channel whats with all the crazy video titles on joshua that they post carats pls report all these videos they are literally trying to get views through spreading rumours and dragging joshua’s name in the dirt
What is wrong with "Netizens"?! When will these idols who work so hard to entertain us be allowed the freedom to have relationships – they are not our possessions and here we are forcing them down the same dangerous spiral that so many other idols and celebrities have been sadly lost to – LEAVE THEM ALONE! It is time for entertainment companies and fans alike to relax the "rules" and expectations for all idols – learn the lessons from the past!
First of all plz change the title we don't want joshua to get more hate just because of this stupid videos that are only made for views.
Second Carats let's support joshua and leave positive comments under his posts!!
We don't care if he dates it's his private life and us fans should not care about it, and most of the hate is coming form antis so i hipe this situation gets better soon ❤
Let's protect joshua❤
I have the same LA cap as Joshua and Mingyu, so are we in a polyamarous relationship? 🤔🤨
This model is married, she is not his girlfriend, she is him fan, another girl maches a lot of touching moments. 18-year-old very beautiful, natural, tall, blue-eyed idol actress and photo model. she is mestizo. She is Chechenka and Korean. She was born in Korea, grew up in Korea and lives fans Joshua are sure that he is dating in 18 years old girl